Warnings
- AC #6 (
handoff/liquid-implementation.html) is marked partial because Phase 7 has not yet run. v1.6 sequences review before handoff — this APPROVED verdict is intended to unblock that phase. qa-report.jsonran with limited browser-eval (static DOM + screenshot only). IntersectionObserver sticky show/hide and the size-sheet open/close are wired in code but not dynamically exercised. Recommend a CDP run before merge.- Three taste findings are all severity=low and do not trigger REVISE. Forwarded as polish notes.
Continuity check pass
No section in the wireframe has disposition=REMOVE. All 12 sections are EXTEND. No protected-removal-overrides needed.
Claims check pass
All 9 verified claims ship with allowed_copy phrasing. The two non-verified claims (10-year warranty — partial; 100-night sleep trial — unverified) render only as {{ claim-needed }} placeholder chips in the prototype and are absent from schema.jsonld. v1.4 clean.
QA check pass
qa-report.json status=ok, findings array empty. Browser-eval was static DOM + screenshot only — see warnings.
Acceptance criteria 12 met 1 partial
| # | Criterion | Status | Rationale |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | brief.resolved.yaml exists with merged store + page-type defaults; wiki_paths + forbidden_claim_patterns + design_reference_theme + sticky_atc_pattern + comparison_section_policy + size_selector_pattern + buybox_pattern all flow through | met | All seven listed structures populated; forbidden_claim_patterns has organic + manufacturing lists; size_selector_pattern.control=dropdown with 12 rows; buybox_pattern.preserve_as_is=true. |
| 2 | runs/<run_id>/intake/ contains theme.json, theme.html, patterns.html, page-audit.html, inspiration.html | met | All five intake artifacts present (existence verified, contents not read — fresh-eyes posture preserved). |
| 3 | runs/<run_id>/design/ contains wireframe.html, copy.html, claims.html, seo.html, graphics.html, technical-notes.html, schema.jsonld | met | All seven design artifacts present. |
| 4 | runs/<run_id>/prototype/ contains index.html, README.md, qa-report.json | met | All three prototype artifacts present. |
| 5 | runs/<run_id>/review/ contains verdict.html (validates against verdict.schema.json) | met | This verdict.html is the artifact; embedded data block validates. |
| 6 | runs/<run_id>/handoff/ contains liquid-implementation.html (validates against implementation-handoff.schema.json) | partial | handoff/ is empty at review time. v1.6 sequences review BEFORE handoff — this AC is the Phase 7 deliverable that an APPROVED verdict unblocks. Not a substantive design failure. |
| 7 | design/schema.jsonld passes bin/validate-schema-jsonld.py against design/claims.html (zero v1.4 violations) | met | bin/validate-schema-jsonld.py returned OK. Zero placeholders and zero partial/unverified strings in JSON-LD. |
| 8 | prototype/qa-report.json findings_total == 0 | met | Findings array empty; status=ok. |
| 9 | Zero matches for forbidden_claim_patterns.natural_harmony_collection.organic_claims patterns in copy.html, prototype/index.html, schema.jsonld | met | Grep across 10 organic-claim patterns: zero customer-facing hits in prototype/index.html and schema.jsonld. Hits in copy.html are confined to voice-notes / prohibition-discussion regions (“GOTS/GOLS/RWS deliberately excluded”), not shipped copy. |
| 10 | Zero matches for forbidden_claim_patterns.natural_harmony_collection.manufacturing_location_claims patterns in copy.html, prototype/index.html, schema.jsonld | met | Grep across 15 manufacturing-location patterns: zero customer-facing hits anywhere. Two hits in graphics.html photo-direction notes (“no Made in UAE packaging”) are explicit prohibitions, not claims. |
| 11 | Comparison section in wireframe + copy + prototype contains exactly the three NHC tiers (Essentia / Select / Reserve), no external competitors | met | Prototype comparison block renders three tier cards (Essentia/Essential, Select/Premier (current-highlighted), Reserve/Signature). Zero Avocado/Naturalmat/Simba/DreamCloud/Vi-Spring strings in customer-facing comparison surfaces. |
| 12 | Size selector in wireframe + prototype is a dropdown with compare-at + current price per option (NOT button chips) | met | Buy-box block 1 explicitly labelled “Size selector (DROPDOWN, not chips)”; renders trigger + open-state list of all 12 sizes with compare-at strikethrough + green current price per row. Desktop sticky uses native <select>; mobile sticky opens a bottom-sheet tile grid. |
| 13 | Sticky ATC — mobile split top-strip + bottom-footer (with size-trigger-opens-bottom-sheet); desktop top fixed bar + paired in-page nav row (Overview / Reviews / FAQ / Materials & Construction / Product Specs) | met | Three sticky regions ship: #mobile-sticky-top (rating+title), #mobile-sticky-bottom (size-chip + ATC, opens #size-sheet), #desktop-sticky (full bar + paired nav with five anchors). IntersectionObserver wired against the inline ATC. Nav label “Layers & Materials” substitutes for the brief’s “Materials & Construction” — equivalent meaning, not a violation; flagged as a low-severity taste finding (review-01). |
Taste findings 3 low
-
review-01 · low · Desktop in-page nav label drift: “Layers & Materials” vs brief’s “Materials & Construction” (section: sticky-add-to-cart)
The brief’s sticky_atc_pattern lists the in-page nav links as Overview/Reviews/FAQ/Layers & Materials/Product Specs while AC #13 names “Materials & Construction”. The prototype follows the sticky_atc_pattern wording but creates a hairline documentation crack with AC #13.
Lock the brief to “Layers & Materials” (preferred — matches materials-led voice) or flip the prototype label. Single source-of-truth lives in stores/huxberry.yaml.sticky_atc_pattern.
-
review-02 · low · Sticky-ATC button copy is generic “Add to cart” — leaves a trust-anchor on the table (section: sticky-add-to-cart)
Both desktop top-bar and mobile bottom-footer CTAs read “Add to cart”. Calm, evidence-led voice would carry a verified trust anchor (e.g. “Add to cart · Made to order, ships in 5 days”) without becoming hype.
Optional Phase 7 copy polish — the delivery promise is verified (claims[8]), so this is voice-strength, not a claims risk.
-
review-03 · low · Hero credibility lever — Wisewool supplier-cert stack is buried (section: hero)
Huxberry’s strongest credibility lever on this PDP — Wisewool’s B Corp + Land to Market + FernMark stack on the NZ wool layer — surfaces only at trust-strip and certifications. The hero leads with size+price+“natural mattress for Dubai” framing.
Future copy pass: consider replacing one trust pill with “B Corp NZ wool” or similar. Not a blocker — current trust triple is consistent with the verified claims manifest.